Economist Jeffrey Sachs does not believe that the US will provide billions in new aid to Ukraine. He believes the newly elected US Congress will primarily focus on reducing the cost of living. Sachs hopes that the Democrats will evolve into a „peace party.“
What caused American voters to vote as they did?
The voters delivered a clear verdict on Trump’s presidency. By the latest Associated Press counts, the Democrats have won at least 54 seats in the Senate and more than 250 in the House, which would be their largest House majority since 2008. Trump’s policies are widely seen to have failed badly, especially his economic policies. These failures were linked above all to his disastrous war on Iran, which was both a failure of policy and a gross violation of international law. Trump himself conceded on election night that “a part of it was Iran,” and Vice President Vance was blunter the next day, writing that “the reason we lost is the war.” In the AP Voter Poll, about 60 percent of voters said that the decision to use military force against Iran was wrong, and about 90 percent called the cost of living a crucial or major factor in their vote.
Are they truly opposed to the Iran war or were they just angry about high prices at the gas pump?
Voters did not have to choose between the two, because the war and the cost of living were the same issue. Gasoline cost around $2.80 per gallon before the war began on February 28, rose by about 55 percent by mid-May, and averaged $4.43 in September. The 10-year Treasury yield rose from below 4 percent before the war to above 5 percent in the autumn, raising the cost of every mortgage and car loan, while the Pentagon sought more than $200 billion in supplemental war funding. Voters also made a deeper link. The wars in the Middle East over the past 25 years, in Afghanistan, Iraq, Syria, Libya, Lebanon and now Iran, most of them fought at Israel’s urging or alongside Israel, have cost the United States trillions of dollars, with a loss of prestige, repeated failures of policy, and rising costs to consumers. Brown University’s Costs of War project puts the cost of the post-2001 wars at about $8 trillion. Americans have watched this for a generation, and they are tired of it.
Trump once campaigned on the slogan „no more endless wars“ – he was successful, because back then the Democrats were running these wars. Can people trust that this time it will be different?
No, not necessarily. The Democrats and Republicans have both backed the U.S. military-industrial complex, and both have served the Israel lobby. Trump promised no more endless wars and then launched a war on Iran. The Biden administration refused in December 2021 to negotiate with Russia over NATO enlargement, joined Britain in blocking the Istanbul agreement in April 2022, and armed Israel throughout the destruction of Gaza. Voters punished the Democrats for this in 2024. Among Americans who voted for Biden in 2020 but not for Harris in 2024, ending Israel’s violence in Gaza was the most frequently cited reason. The Democrats now need to draw the right lesson from their victory, which is to become the Peace Party. Trust will come from deeds rather than slogans, beginning with the restoration of the constitutional authority of Congress over war and its power of the purse, so that no President can again take the country to war on a whim or at the behest of domestic or foreign lobbies.
Would a Democratic congress try to push Trump to a return to the level of military, financial and political support seen under Joe Biden?
No, because the Democratic caucus will be divided between older hawks and younger doves. Of course, the voters want the doves to win this battle. A New York Times/Siena poll in May found that roughly three-quarters of Democratic voters oppose U.S. military and economic assistance to Israel, and there is no public appetite for a return to the tens of billions of dollars a year that Washington sent to Ukraine under Biden. The American voters are tired of militarism and war, and voters elsewhere feel the same way. Netanyahu lost his majority in the Israeli election on October 27. Only 10 percent of Germans say they are satisfied with Chancellor Merz, the lowest rating ever recorded for a German chancellor, and President Macron’s approval fell to 15 percent in October. In Bulgaria, Iliana Iotova, who favors dialogue with Moscow, won the presidency on November 1 with more than 58 percent of the vote.
Democrats have so far denied all talks with Russia. Does Trump have room left to negotiate something with the Russians?
Yes, Trump still has room to make peace with Russia. The talks resuming in Abu Dhabi on November 10 and 11, the first trilateral meeting of the United States, Russia and Ukraine since February, show that the channel is open. The question is whether Trump is competent enough to use it, and sadly I doubt that he is. Making peace would require him to address the causes of the war, above all NATO enlargement and Ukraine’s neutrality, rather than haggling over lines on a map. He would also have to face down the warmongers in Congress, in the military-industrial complex, and, incredibly, in Europe. His policy so far has swung back and forth between pressure on Kyiv and pressure on Moscow, and his war on Iran has squandered much of his political capital. If Trump does seek a real settlement, the new Congress should not obstruct him, and the smart Democrats will not.
Chuck Schumer has called Vladimir Putin a “thug and a butcher” and a “murderous dictator.” Hakeem Jeffries used similar words. Do you expect that they will change their tune or escalate?
This will test their intelligence as politicians. Their approach to Russia contributed to the Democrats’ defeat in 2024, because voters held the Biden administration responsible for the costs of Biden’s wars, including the energy shock that followed the escalation of the Ukraine war in 2022, when gasoline topped $5 per gallon for the first time. The American people do not like the Ukraine war, just as they do not like the Iran war. Name-calling is not a foreign policy. President Kennedy negotiated the Limited Test Ban Treaty with Khrushchev less than a year after the Cuban Missile Crisis, and President Reagan, who had called the Soviet Union an evil empire, went on to sign the INF Treaty with Gorbachev. Schumer and Jeffries can follow those examples and support diplomacy, or they can escalate and try to lead their party back into the trap that cost it the White House in 2024. To choose the latter course would be to defy the voters.
After the clash between Donald Trump and Zelenskyy in the Oval Office in February 2025, Chuck Schumer said Trump and Vance were “doing Putin’s dirty work,” while Hakeem Jeffries called the meeting “appalling“. Can Zelenskyy expect a new approach to the war from Washington?
No. Congress will be divided and largely uninterested in Ukraine, and all eyes will be focused on 2028. The new majority’s priorities will be the cost of living, not a new aid package for Kyiv. If the Democrats are smart, they will urge an end to the Ukraine war rather than its continuation. President Zelensky should also represent his own citizens. Some 75 percent of Ukrainians support negotiations with Russia to end the war. He would serve them best by negotiating seriously in Abu Dhabi and beyond on the basis of Ukraine’s neutrality, rather than on hoping for a new wave of American support that is not coming.
Vicente Gonzalez took part in a direct meeting with Russian lawmakers. Jeanne Shaheen responded by demanding an investigation into how that visit was allowed to happen. Isn’t there a strong anti-Russian sentiment?
Yes, there is strong anti-Russian sentiment in the Washington political class, and it is bipartisan. When Representative Gonzalez, a Democrat, joined four Republican colleagues in March in a meeting with members of the Russian Duma, Senator Shaheen, the ranking Democrat on the Foreign Relations Committee, and Senator Wicker, the Republican chairman of the Armed Services Committee, demanded that the administration explain how the visit had been allowed. A former congressman called the American participants traitors. It is a very sad and dangerous state of affairs when talking to the other side is treated as treason. During the Cold War, American and Soviet legislators, scientists and officials met regularly, and those contacts helped to keep the peace. There is Russophobia in the political class in Washington as in the political class in Berlin, Brussels, Paris, and London. It is not shared by the voters, who want the wars to end, and Russophobic warmongers will meet the same fate at the ballot box as Trump’s party did this month.
The Europeans have mostly been in line with hawkish Democrats. Can they derail any kind of negotiation or settlement?
They may try to delay a settlement, but I do not believe they can stop one. Europe has largely excluded itself from the negotiations. No European government will be at the table in Abu Dhabi, and Europe’s role has been limited to talks on post-war security guarantees and reconstruction, for a war that Europe currently has no plans to end. The Europeans and Zelensky can condemn more Ukrainians to die in a useless war by insisting on conditions that Russia has rejected for years, such as the deployment of European troops in Ukraine after a ceasefire. Better, they should stand with Ukraine by pressing for a sensible peace agreement. The call that President Stubb and Prime Minister Støre held with President Putin on October 27 showed that some European leaders understand this. Germany, France and the EU institutions should follow this approach.
Democrats could by congressional control investigate, restrict funding and politically constrain the Witkoff-Kushner channel. Do you see this danger?
The Democrats would be very foolish to try. The problem with the Witkoff-Kushner channel is not that it talks to Russia but that it has been ineffective. It met repeatedly in the first weeks of the year, then stalled for nine months, and it resumes this week in Abu Dhabi. It has treated the war as a real-estate negotiation over lines on a map, rather than addressing the causes of the war, above all NATO enlargement and Ukraine’s neutrality. If the Democrats use their powers of oversight, they should insist on a serious diplomatic strategy, not on shutting down talks. In any event, it is not for Washington alone or even mainly to end a European war. This is Europe’s responsibility, including the EU, Ukraine, and Russia together.
Isn’t Trump a lame duck regarding Ukraine war?
Yes, largely. With the Democrats in control of both houses of Congress, Trump will struggle to pass legislation, and his authority abroad is diminished. Both Moscow and Kyiv will be looking beyond him in any event. Europe should now choose to negotiate peace. Europe will live alongside Russia after this administration has gone, and will gain tremendously from a peace settlement and could lose disastrously from continued war.
With whom should German politicians speak to create some momentum towards ending the war?
I would suggest ignoring the Americans. They are not the point. Nor are they Europe’s security. I would sit down within Europe and revive the OSCE – largely without the Americans.
Chancellor Merz should speak directly with President Putin and President Zelensky, as President Stubb and Prime Minister Støre have done. This is overwhelmingly a European issue, not an American issue. Foreign Minister Wadephul, who met Foreign Minister Lavrov in New York in September, should follow with a visit to Moscow. Germany has a particular responsibility. German reunification rested on the assurances given in 1990 that NATO would not move eastward, and Germany witnessed the February 21, 2014 agreement with Yanukovych just before the coup on February 22 but failed to condemn the coup. Germany also helped broker Minsk II but also failed to defend it. The war will end based on the concept of indivisible security for Europe: no NATO enlargement, Ukraine’s neutrality, Ukraine’s candidacy for EU membership as a neutral country, an armistice line, arms control, and human rights for Russians and Ukrainians based on Europe-wide standards under the Helsinki Final Act and the OSCE. Germany should put that framework on the table. With only 10 percent of Germans satisfied with the Chancellor, Merz has every reason to change course and press for peace based on the principle of indivisible security.
